Government U-Turn On Disability Benefits Leaves Budget In Disarray

Stephen Crabb scraps cuts that prompted departure of Iain Duncan Smith, and sparks uncertainty over further pledges.


Powered by Guardian.co.ukThis article titled “Government U-turn on disability benefits leaves budget in disarray” was written by Rowena Mason Political correspondent, for theguardian.com on Monday 21st March 2016 19.10 UTC

Ministers will entirely cancel £4bn of cuts to disability benefits and no longer have plans to make savings from the welfare budget, Stephen Crabb, the new work and pensions secretary, has said.

Crabb also acknowledged the government may not have had a sufficiently human approach to welfare cuts in the past, after Iain Duncan Smith resigned from the job on Friday alleging that Downing Street was unfairly targeting the working poor.


His comments create uncertainty over whether the Conservative pre-election pledge to make £12bn of cuts to the welfare budget will be now met, although Crabb did not specify how long the government would hold off from reducing benefits again.

The trigger for Duncan Smith’s departure was the Treasury’s insistence that cuts of around £1bn a year to disability benefits be rushed out so that they could deliver savings for Wednesday’s budget, which at the same time offered tax cuts for higher earners.

George Osborne has not appeared in public to defend his budget, which now has a £4.4bn black hole in its numbers, or rebut the charge of Duncan Smith that he produced a “deeply unfair budget”.

However, David Cameron defended himself and the chancellor in the Commons on Monday, saying that they run a “modern, compassionate, one-nation government”.

Crabb continued in the same tone as he confirmed the cuts to the disability benefit known as the personal independence payment would be totally scrapped, three days after government sources indicated a U-turn was on the way.

In his first Commons statement in the job, the cabinet minister paid tribute to Duncan Smith and struck a conciliatory tone for the benefit of Conservative rebels who believe the Treasury’s budget was not fairly balanced.

“Behind every statistic there is a human being and perhaps sometimes in government we forget that,” Crabb said. “After discussing this issue over the weekend with the prime minister and the chancellor we have no further plans to make welfare savings beyond the very substantial savings legislated for by parliament two weeks ago.”

Crabb’s comments mean the government is standing by the cuts to disability benefit known as the employment and support allowance for the work-related activity group.

‘Practically every cabinet minister is here today. Whatever has happened to the chancellor of the exchequer?’ asked Jeremy Corbyn.
‘Practically every cabinet minister is here today. Whatever has happened to the chancellor of the exchequer?’ asked Jeremy Corbyn. Photograph: PA

He also hinted that the level of the chancellor’s welfare cap could be revised upwards, after Duncan Smith said the figure was “arbitrary” and risked dividing the nation.

“The principle of a welfare cap is the right one … We do need that discipline. As we are required to do we will review the level of the cap at the autumn statement as the OBR requires us to do, but I want to repeat that we have no further plans to make welfare savings beyond those legislated for two weeks ago that we are now focused on implementing,” he said.

Responding to the statement, Owen Smith, the shadow work and pensions secretary, welcome the U-turn as a “good start” but pressed him to go further in changing the government’s approach to welfare cuts by scrapping the bedroom tax and ESA cuts.

“Among the many extraordinary truths spoken by his predecessor yesterday, was the shameful admission that these two-nation Tories target their cuts on those who they think won’t vote for them,” Smith said. “The new man in post will have to work very hard to wash that stain out.”

Earlier, Cameron lavished praise on Osborne, in his first appearance since civil war broke out in the Conservative party, as he sought to fend off Duncan Smith’s criticism that the nation’s finances are being balanced on the backs of the working poor.

During a statement on last week’s EU summit, Cameron launched into a list of the policies he has implemented that he said were taking children out of poverty and getting more people into jobs.

He said that work was only possible because of Osborne’s stewardship of the economy and pledged to continue on the same path, despite Duncan Smith’s argument that the current balance of austerity risks dividing the nation.

“All of this is driven by a deeply held conviction that everyone in Britain should have the chance to make the most of their lives,” Cameron said.

“None of this would be possible if it wasn’t for the actions of this government and the work of my right honourable friend the chancellor in turning our economy around. We can only improve life chances if our economy is secure and strong.

“Without sound public finances you end up having to raise taxes or make even deeper cuts in spending. You don’t get more opportunity, you get less opportunity that way. We know when that happens it is working people that suffer as we saw in Labour’s recession. We must continue to cut the deficit, control the cost of welfare and live within our means.”

To some cheers from Tory backbenchers, he added: “We must not burden our children and grandchildren with debts we did not have the courage to pay off ourselves. We will continue with this approach in full. We are a modern, compassionate, one-nation Conservative government.”

The chancellor has faced calls from Labour to resign and prompted anger among some Tory backbenchers after he was forced to withdraw planned cuts to disability benefits that would have saved £4.4bn.

Osborne, whose leadership chances have been damaged by the fiasco, refused to answer an urgent question in the House of Commons about the unravelling budget figures, sending one of his deputies, David Gauke, instead.

Responding to the prime minister’s defence of his and Osborne’s record, the Labour leader, Jeremy Corbyn, accused Cameron of “covering for his friend”.

“The prime minister is here today. The work and pensions secretary is here today. Practically every cabinet minister is here today. Whatever has happened to the chancellor of the exchequer?” he asked.

Corbyn said the budget had an “enormous hole in it brought about by a temporary retreat on the issue of the personal independence payment”. He said it was the “first time of his memory in parliament that a government’s budget has fallen apart in the space of two days”.

The Labour leader urged Cameron to guarantee there will be no further DWP cuts and condemned the budget for having “inequality as its core”.

guardian.co.uk © Guardian News & Media Limited 2010

Published via the Guardian News Feed plugin for WordPress.

Get News Updates!

Register to receive a notification each time we publish a new story. Don't worry, we'll never spam you and it's easy to cancel at any time. Service provided by Google Feedburner.

- Sponsored Content -

Trending Now

UK pensioners ‘suffering the worst poverty rate in western Europe’

Tories warned against further rises to the state pension age.

Nearly half of DWP staff are dependent on benefits to make ends meet

At least 40% of DWP staff are claiming benefits to top-up low wages.

Social housing tenants who damage their home ‘should face benefit sanctions’, report says

Report claims "rogue tenants" have cost taxpayers in London around £3.4million since 2014.

A homeless person dies every 19 hours in austerity Britain

Services are failing to protect homelessness people, say campaigners.

The Latest

Nearly half of DWP staff are dependent on benefits to make ends meet

At least 40% of DWP staff are claiming benefits to top-up low wages.

New DWP Secretary refuses to commit to ending the benefit freeze

Thérèse Coffey also claimed there is "no causal link" between the two-child benefit limit and rising child poverty.

Tenancy reforms leave private renters at risk of ‘revenge evictions’

Tenants who complain about or request repairs unfairly removed from their homes.

Social housing tenants who damage their home ‘should face benefit sanctions’, report says

Report claims "rogue tenants" have cost taxpayers in London around £3.4million since 2014.

New SNP childcare pledge to ‘lift families out of poverty’

Free childcare pledge to save families £4,500 per year for each child.

2.6 million mid-life workers expect to leave their job to care for a relative

Government urged to invest in long-term and sustainable social care funding so that more people can remain in work.

Follow Us

16,668FansLike
9,373FollowersFollow

More Articles Like This